Home / Contact / Stories,
News & Reports / Photos
Worldwide Gay Life,
Sites and Insights
Stories + Photographs + News + Reports + Links
Gay Thailand
News & Reports July 2005--International
Conference
Also
see Globalgayz stories on Gay Thailand 1999 and 2001
Also
see:
Gay Thailand News & Reports 2000-03
Gay Thailand News & Reports 2004-05
Gay Thailand News & Reports 2007
The Nation
Newspaper, Bangkok
July 4,
2005
1
Asian Queer Studies Conference in Bangkok
Asian Queer Studies Conference in Bangkok ‘Queer’ conference
attracts big response
By Veena Thoopkrajae
Bangkok will host the first ever “International Conference
of Asian Queer Studies” from Thursday to Saturday – a
huge academic gathering which is expected to shed new light on gender
studies thanks
to its broad spectrum of topics covering issues relating to Asian
homosexual and transgender groups.
Entitled “Sexualities, Genders and Rights in Asia: 1st International
Conference of Asian Queer Studies”, the conference brings scholars,
human rights advocates, artists and film makers involved in researching
and documenting Asian homosexuals and transgenders to meet in Bangkok
in order to support academics, especially those undertaking postgraduate
studies on Asian homosexuals and transgenders.
A joint initiative of the Office of Human Rights Studies and Social Development
at Mahidol University in Thailand and the Australia-based AsiaPacifiQueer
Network, the conference will feature over 50 speakers on LGBTQ (lesbian,
gay, bi-sexual, transgender, queer) issues, with more than 150 presentations
from around the world, 70 per cent of which will come from Asian researchers.
“
We were quite shocked with the feedback as we expected around 50 papers
but as we were approaching our deadline in December last year, there
were as many as 120 papers submitted to our website,” said
Peter A Jackson, an organising committee member.
Jackson said Asian countries including Thailand, Japan, China, and
India are experiencing a boom in studies on homosexuals and transgenders.
The
conference will create an international forum for Asian “queer
studies” which will directly benefit postgraduate researchers
working on the topics.
He said one of the obstacles is the lack of support. “The discrimination
is still there for those who want to study these kind of topics.
There is also a lack of balanced opinions on the issue. The current
problems
in Thailand are the same as those experienced by western academics
over the past 20 to 30 years.”
The conference is aimed at covering all facets of Asian LGBTQ and each
day will have a thematic focus reflected in the topics covered in the
plenary sessions as well as in the streams of panels programmed for each
day. The first day on July 7 will concentrate on rights issue while the
second day will have culture as its theme and the last day will focus
on health issues.
In addition to supporting researchers, the 1st International Conference
of Asian Queer Studies is aimed at building bridges between NGOs
and academics. “It is necessary that NGOs receive accurate information
from academic research if they are to work effectively,” said
Jackson.
Keynote speakers will be Professor Vitit Muntabhorn of Chulalongkorn
University and Professor Josephine Ho of Taiwan’s National Central
University. Vitit, Unesco’s biennial Human Rights Education Prize
winner in 2004, will speak on July 7 on the topic, “Sexualities,
Genders and Rights in International Law: Implications for the Asian Region.” Ho,
the founder of the Centre for the Study of Sexualities – Asia’s
first academic institute devoted to supporting the study of same-sex
and transgender cultures – will deliver her keynote address on
July 8 on the topic, “Is Global Governance Bad for Asian Queers?”
Jackson said among the diverse issues, the analysis of the media,
which looks at the representation of homosexuality in the media,
is one of
the highlights. “The stereotyping of gays is a big issue. To
analyse and criticise the media is important for the promotion of
rights.”
He said analysis of the Internet is another interesting topic. The Internet
is one of the most popular forms of media used by the global LGBTQ community.
The tremendous responses of the participants to the upcoming conference
alone, shows how the group actively communicate via cyberspace.
Other topics to be discussed in the panel sessions will include social
persecution and legal discrimination against sexual minorities in Asia;
gay, lesbian and transgender citizenship and rights; homosexuals and
transgenders in Asian cinema and literature; the globalisation of homosexual
cultures; Asian homosexual diasporas in the West; and the impact of HIV/AIDS
on Asian same-sex communities.
The legal recognition of sex-changes will be discussed by speakers
from across Asia, including Japan, Malaysia, Thailand and Iran. Homosexual
women’s issues will also be highlighted, with representatives
from lesbian organisations from Japan, China, the Philippines, India,
Thailand
and other countries presenting panels on the rights of women who
love women.
The plenary speakers on July 8 will also touch upon the status of
Asia’s
homosexuals and transgenders. Many people believe in the “local” or “indigenous” character
of LGBTQ identities and communities within each region while the
others assume that modern queer Asia is ultimately borrowing western
models
of gay and lesbian identity. Others emphasise the typically hybrid
nature of queer identities across the planet. This panel will explore
the debate.
“
Gay and lesbian studies started in America but the theory is unlikely
to be applicable to the rest of the world thanks to the different cultures
and historical backgrounds. The meeting will be a good chance to help
to expand the database of information for Asian queer studies,” said
Jackson.
The Nation, Bangkok, Thailand
http://nationmultimedia.com/2005/07/09/opinion/index.php?news=opinion_17977936.html
July 09,
2005
2
Conference shows Thailand is a gay paradise
By Veena
Thoopkrajae
Despite a number of items in the news impacting negatively on Thailand’s
image, such as the country being downgraded in international free-press
rankings or the latest airport scandal, the country has just taken
a positive step by hosting the first International Conference on Asian
Queer Studies, which ends today.
Starting modestly as an initiative of the Asian National University
of Australia (ANU) with the cooperation of Thailand’s Mahidol
University, the conference has drawn more than 500 delegates from around
the world who have participated in panel discussions and presentations
on over 160 studies on lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer
(LGBTQ) issues.
This surge in academic studies is proof that the time has come for
Asian countries to look into this issue as a relevant factor in larger
political, economic and social issues. As a host coutnry, Thailand
has shown the world its broadmindedness and liberal stance concerning
academic studies.
The effort of Mahidol University demonstrates the willingness of
Thai academics to join the rest of the world in promoting a better
understanding
of LGBTGQ studies.
Outside the academic world, the country already has a reputation
as a friendly destination for the LGBTQ group. The gay-pride parade,
an
annual gay cultural event held on Silom Road, attracts tourists from
all over the region.
Thailand’s Babylon bathhouse is regarded as one of the best sanctuaries
for gay people from around the world. Travel guides, including those
published by the Lonely Planet, have put Thailand on the world’s
gay-friendly map.
Thai gays have also welcomed the move of Singapore’s “Nation
Party”, held on that country’s Nation Day, to Phuket this
November after the event was deemed “contrary to the public interest” in
the city-state.
Many factors add to Thailand’s reputation as a friendly place
for LGBTQ people. For one, the country does not place restrictions
on these groups. Cases of violence against gays and lesbian groups
are very rare, and there is no obvious social hatred for these groups.
In addition, our laws do not discriminate against these groups. If
there is a major obstacle in Thailand it is the stereotyping of these
groups in the media, which seems to be a global issue for LGBTQ groups.
More importantly, homosexuals in Thailand, local or foreign, are
not in any way considered criminals in the legal realm, neither are
they
regarded as mentally ill in medical circles. From a religious perspective,
gays and lesbians in Thailand are not, as a general rule, branded
as sinners.
In the social sphere, the country has benefited from LGBTQ groups
both directly and indirectly. The direct gain, which no one can really
argue
with, has been in the field of human resources. Members of LGBTQ
groups are often at the top of their chosen professions, as designers,
artists,
film-makers, architects, academics, business people, diplomats, athletes
and even politicians.
Indirectly, Thailand’s LGBTQ groups have brought the Kingdom
fame and commercial gain. Our gay-genre films including “Satree
Lek” and “Satree Lek 2”, along with “The Adventure
of Iron Pussy”, have been invited to various high-profile international
film festivals. “Satree Lek” and its sequel also brought
home foreign currency after being distributed in more than 20 countries
around the world.
Such movies also offer a positive image of homosexuality in Thailand
and have been fundamental in fostering the understanding of sexuality
in this country and elsewhere. When it comes to tourism, the country
has a reputation as a “gay paradise”. Thailand offers entertainment
that is friendly and safe for LGBTQ tourists from around the world,
especially those from countries in the region like Malaysia and Singapore.
On the other hand, straight people also enjoy interacting with the
homosexual community. All positive signs of tolerance regarding different
sexual orientations should be encouraged.
The conference, despite its academic focus, is part of a wider message
that Thailand is sending to the LGBTQ world. The country has already
been put on the gay-friendly map, and better understanding through
the academic forum will serve to give notice that the country is
truly a paradise for all, both heterosexuals and homosexuals.
Bangkok
Conference 2005
http://bangkok2005.anu.edu.au/background.php SEXUALITIES,
GENDERS, AND RIGHTS IN ASIA--1st INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE OF ASIAN
QUEER STUDIES
7-9 July 2005
CONTENTS OD THIS ARTICLE:
1 Themes and Background
2 NEW Provisional Conference Program
3 NEW Confirmed Papers & Abstracts
4 Registration
5 NEW Venue, Accommodation & Travel
6 Scholarships
7 Country Contact Groups
8 Photo Gallery
1 Themes and Background
An international interdisciplinary conference on studies of lesbian,
gay, bisexual, transgender, transsexual, bisexual, and queer (LGBTQ)
cultures and communities in Asia will be held in Bangkok, Thailand,
from Thursday 7th to Saturday 9th July, 2005. The main aim of the
conference is to develop linkages between research about Asian
LGBTQ cultures
and communities and promoting recognition and respect for sexual
and gender diversity in the region. A parallel goal of the conference
is
to support and defend the academic legitimacy of research and teaching
about LGBTQ peoples in Asia.
While having long histories and taking diverse cultural and social
forms, LGBTQ peoples across Asia have been widely marginalised
if not actively oppressed by homophobic cultural and political
regimes. Activism
to promote the rights and achieve legal recognition for LGBTQ peoples
dates from the 1970s in countries such as Japan, Thailand, and
the Philippines. Since the 1980s, HIV/AIDS prevention initiatives
have
created the cultural and political space for new forms of LGBTQ
organisation in many Asian countries that previously ignored or
criminalised homosexual
and transgender activities. And in the 1990s, LGBTQ studies emerged
as a rapidly expanding field of academic research in countries
across all the continent's regions, including East Asia, Southeast
Asia, and
South Asia.
Nevertheless, the political gains of Asian LGBTQ activisms remain
limited and tenuous and many Asian countries continue to severely
limit the
freedom of researchers to investigate LGBTQ topics. In some countries
the recent advances in Asian LGBTQ scholarship are now being threatened
by conservative academics, government officials, and others. Furthermore,
much path-breaking work is being conducted by younger scholars,
who often confront institutional resistance to their research and
face
an uncertain future in unsupportive and at times homophobic academic
environments.
The conservative effects of globalisation often compete against
the enabling and empowering technologies provided by the IT revolution.
While this contestation is creating complex new divides amongst
and
within populations across Asia, it is also providing important
opportunities for LGBTQ communities to strengthen their progressive
presence and
to extend their work. The Internet provides opportunities for affirmations
of life and liberty for all populations and Asian LGBTQ communities
are at the forefront of cultural and social movements using the
new technologies to create novel forms of community and to forge
radical
modes of cultural expression. Positive expressions of queer creativity
are becoming increasingly visible presences in the cultural landscapes
of countries across Asia.
In order to defend the gains of recent decades it is important
to take stock of the advances that have been made in LGBTQ research
and activism
in Asia and to enhance existing networks. It is also important
that new strategic linkages between the academy and activists be
developed
in order to further advance the interests of Asian LGBTQ peoples
in the coming years. This conference will provide an opportunity
to demonstrate
the richness, diversity, and international importance of Asian
LGBTQ studies and it will highlight the contribution that academic
research
can make to promoting GLBTQ rights across Asia. The conference
will place particular emphasis on the participation of early-career
scholars
and postgraduate students from the region. The Conference Coordinators
This conference is being organised jointly by the Office of Human
Rights Studies and Social Development at Mahidol University in
Bangkok and
the AsiaPacifiQueer Network.
Mahidol University Office of Human Rights Studies and Social Development
The Mahidol University Office of Human Rights Studies and Social
Development (OHRSD, http://www.humanrights-mu.org/) was established
in 1996 with
the goals of providing education and research opportunities in
the area of human rights. The OHRSD aims to develop the ways and
means
by which human rights are transformed into social and political
realities at the community, national and international levels.
It does so through
educating human rights practitioners, outreach programs to community
and international organisations, and conducting cutting edge research
on issues of crucial importance to human rights. Research supported
by the program aims to both develop academic knowledge of critical
concern to human rights, and provide practical applications of
human rights activities in a wide diversity of fields. The OHRSD
runs a Graduate
Program and its Masters of Human Rights and Social Development
is currently the only Masters level human rights program offered
in the South East
Asian region, attracting students from around the world.
AsiaPacifiQueer Network
AsiaPacifiQueer (APQ) was founded in 2000 as a collaboration between
Australian, New Zealand, and other scholars who are researching
queer cultures and peoples in post-colonial societies of the Asia-Pacific.
APQ has organised three conferences in Australia, edited a special
issue of the Internet journal Intersections, and convened dedicated
APQ streams at several international conferences. Full details
of APQ
activities are listed at the network's website: (http://apq.anu.edu.au/).
APQ's involvement in co-convening this conference emerges from
the highly successful stream of six Asian queer studies panels
convened
at the August 2003 International Convention of Asian Scholars conference
in Singapore. It was a unanimous recommendation of the more than
40 participants in that stream of panels that there is an urgent
need
for an international conference dedicated to the concerns of LGBTQ
research in Asia.
Conference
Organising Committee
(Acharn Ms) Sinith Sitthiraksa, Southeast Asian Studies Program,
Thammasat University, Bangkok
Dr Mike Hayes, Office of Human Rights Studies and Social Development,
Mahidol University, Bangkok
Dr Peter Jackson, Division of Pacific and Asian Studies, Research
School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University
Ms Marjorie Larney, MA Graduate from Human Rights Studies Program
at Mahidol University, Thailand
Dr Mark McLelland, Centre for Critical and Cultural Studies,
University of Queensland
Dr Fran Martin, Dept of English with Cultural Studies, University
of Melbourne
Ms Prempreeda Pramoj Na Ayutthaya, MA Graduate from Sociology
Dept, Chiang Mai University, Thailand
LL.M. Prof. Douglas Sanders, Faculty of Law, Chulalongkorn University,
Bangkok
Mr Therdsak Romjampa, MA Graduate from Dept. of History, Chulalongkorn
University, Thailand
Mr Vitaya Sang-Arun, Director, Cyberfish Media Co., Ltd., BangkokConference
Advisory Committee
(Includes Organising Committee Members)
Prof. Peter Aggleton, Institute of Education, University of London.
Prof. Dennis Altman, Dept of Politics, La Trobe University, Melbourne
Prof. Barbara Watson Andaya, Professor of Asian Studies & Director,
Center for Southeast Asian Studies, University of Hawai'i,
Dr Darren Aoki, Faculty of Oriental Studies, University of Cambridge,
UK.
Dr Chandra Shekhar Balachandran, Chairman, Dharani Trust & Chairman,
The Indian Institute of Geographical Studies, Bangalore, India.
Dr Bidisha Banerjee, Gender Studies Department, St. Lawrence
University, Canton, NY
Prof. Chris Berry, Department of Media and Communications, Goldsmiths
College, University of London
Dr. Evelyn Blackwood, Department of Sociology and Anthropology,
Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana
Dr Tom Boellstorff, Department of Anthropology, University of
California, Irvine & Senior Co-chair of the Society of Lesbian and Gay
Anthropologists (SOLGA).
Dr. Kenneth Chan, University Scholars Programme, National University
of Singapore
Prof. Charnvit Kasetsiri, Southeast Asian Studies Program, Thammasat
University Bangkok
Dr Wei-cheng Raymond Chu, Dept of Foreign Languages and Literatures,
National Taiwan University
Prof. Lawrence Cohen, Department of Anthropology, University
of California, Berkeley.
Mr. Romit Dasgupta, Discipline of Asian Studies, School of Social
and Cultural Studies, University of Western Australia, Perth
Prof. Naifei Ding, English Department, National Central University,
Chung-li, Taiwan
Dr Ross Forman, AHRB Centre for Asian and African Literatures,
SOAS/UCL, University of London
Mr Richard Fung, Faculty of Art, Ontario College of Art and Design,
Canada
Dr J. Neil Garcia, Department of English and Comparative Literature,
University of the Philippines, Diliman, Quezon City, The Philippines.
Ms Mary Ellen Gidah, Centre for the Promotion of Knowledge and
Language Learning, Universiti Malaysia Sabah
Dr Sharyn Graham, School of Social Sciences, Faculty of Arts,
Auckland University of Technology, Auckland, Aotearoa/New Zealand
Dr Mike Hayes, Office of Human Rights Studies and Social Development,
Mahidol University, Bangkok
Mr Hiroshi Hasegawa, Director, JaNP+ (Japanese Network of People
living with HIV/AIDS).
Dr Russell Hiang-Khng Heng, Institute of Southeast Asian Studies,
Singapore.
Prof. Josephine Ho, Coordinator, Center for the Study of Sexualities,
National Central University, Taiwan (http://sex.ncu.edu.tw)
Mr Hitoshi Ishida, Sociology and Sexuality Studies, Chuo University,
Japan
Dr Peter Jackson, Division of Pacific and Asian Studies, Research
School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University
Dr Karen Kelsky, Dept. of Anthropology and East Asian Languages
and Cultures, University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign
Dr. Olivia Khoo, School of Theatre, Film and Dance, University
of New South Wales, Sydney
Mr Saleem Kidwai, Independent Scholar, New Delhi
Ms Noriko Kohashi, Independent Scholar, Japan
Dr Helen Hok-Sze Leung, Department of Women's Studies, Simon
Fraser University, Canada
Dr David CL Lim, Asia Research Institute, National University
of Singapore
Prof. Liang-ya Liou, Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures,
National Taiwan University.
Dr Mark McLelland, Centre for Critical and Cultural Studies,
University of Queensland.
Dr Claire Maree, Department of English, Tsuda College, Japan
Dr Fran Martin, Dept of English with Cultural Studies, University
of Melbourne
Mr Narupon Duangwises, Princess Sirinthorn Anthropology Centre,
Bangkok
Dr. Dede Oetomo, Reader, Post-Graduate Program, University of
Surabaya, Indonesia.
Dr Baden Offord, Senior Lecturer in Cultural Studies & History,
School of Arts, Southern Cross University, Lismore, Australia
Dr Frank Proschan, Center for Folklife and Cultural Heritage,
Smithsonian Institution, Washington
Dr L. Ramakrishnan, Country Director, Programs and Research,
SAATHII: Solidarity and Action Against the HIV Infection in India,
Chennai,
India
LL.M. Prof. Douglas Sanders, Faculty of Law, Chulalongkorn University,
Bangkok
Mr Sant Suwatcharapinun, Faculty of Architecture, Chiang Mai
University.
Dr. Wolfram Schaffar, Department for Southeast Asian Studies,
University of Bonn, Germany
Dr Akiko Shimizu, Faculty of Economics, Chuo University, Japan
(Acharn Ms) Sinith Sitthiraksa, Southeast Asian Studies Program,
Thammasat University, Bangkok
Dr Sriprapha Petcharamesree, Office of Human Rights Studies and
Social Development, Mahidol University, Bangkok
Assoc. Prof. Gerard Sullivan, Faculty of Education and Social
Work, University of Sydney
Mr Hiroyuki Taniguchi, Institute for Social Science, Chuo University,
Japan
Dr Teh Yik Koon, Faculty of Social and Human Development, Universiti
Utara Malaysia. Sintok, Kedah, Malaysia.
Mr Chung To, Chairperson, Chi Heng Foundation, China
Prof. John Treat, Chairman, Department of East Asian Languages
and Literatures, Yale University.
Prof. Ruth Vanita, Department of Liberal Studies and Women's
Studies, University of Montana.
Mr Vitaya Sang-Arun, Director, Cyberfish Media Co., Ltd., Bangkok
Dr James Welker, Department of British and American Studies,
Nanzan University, Nagoya, Japan.
Mr Jan Wijngaarden, Chief, HIV/AIDS Coordination Unit, UNESCO
Asia-Pacific Regional Bureau for Education, Bangkok.
Dr. Sam J. Winter, Division of Learning, Development and Diversity,
Faculty of Education, University of Hong Kong Mr. Ken Wong, School
of Professional and Continuing Education, University of Hong
Kong
Mr Huso Yi, Senior Research Associate, Institute for International
Research on Youth at Risk, National Development and Research
Institutes, Inc. New York, & Deputy Director, Korean Sexual Minority Culture
and Rights Center, Seoul, Korea (http://kscrc.org).
Graduate Students Advisory Caucus
To further the conference objective of encouraging the participation
of early-career scholars and postgraduate students, a graduate
student's international advisory caucus has been set up. Current
members of this
caucus include:
Ms Elisabeth Engebretsen, Dept. of Anthropology, London School
of Economics and Political Science, United Kingdom.
Ms Lucetta Kam, Postgraduate Student, Gender Studies, The Chinese
University of Hong Kong
Mr Alvin Koh, Dept of English with Cultural Studies, University
of Melbourne
Mr Eng-Beng Lim, Dissertation Fellow, Critical Studies, Department
of Theater, UCLA School of Theater, Film and Television & Associate
Global Fellow, UCLA International Institute
Mr Jin-hyung Park, Korean Sexual Minority's Culture & Right
Center (KSCRC) (http://www.kscrc.org), Seoul, Korea
Ms Prempreeda Pramoj Na Ayutthaya, MA Graduate, Sociology Dept,
Chiang Mai University, Thailand
Mr Therdsak Romjampa, MA Graduate, Dept. of History, Chulalongkorn
University, Thailand
Mr Katsuhiko Suganuma, MA Graduate, State University of New York
at Albany
Ms Wong Ying Wuen, Postgraduate Student, Southeast Asian Studies
Program, National University of Singapore A note
about "queer"
The conference organisers use the word "queer" in both its
current senses. "Queer" is both a shorthand for the full
diversity of homoerotic, transgender, and transsexual behaviours, identities,
and cultures as well as a term describing critical forms of theory
that draw on poststructuralist and postcolonial analyses. In its conferences
and publications the AsiaPacifiQueer Network emphasises the need to
rethink queer theory in Asian contexts, simultaneously critiquing homophobic
discourses and practices in Asia and questioning the eurocentrism of
Western accounts of sexuality and gender.
CONFERENCE
STREAMS
Panels and papers have been programmed into several thematic streams
to permit participants with specific interests to attend as many
sessions as possible on the topic that is most relevant to them.
The conference streams are:
Cinemas and Media
Gay Cultures
Diasporas
Health
Rights and Activism
Transgenders
Women Who Love Women
CONFIRMED PAPERS AND ABSTRACTS
As at Sunday 15 May the following papers have been confirmed for
presentation at the conference. This list includes everyone who
has had their abstract accepted and who has also registered for
the conference. The papers are listed by alphabetical order of
the presenter’s surname.
Nasirin Bin Abdillah, University of Malaya
Mapping Awk(queer)ness in the 21st Century Malaysian Literary Landscape
This paper addresses the general question of how queerness affects
contemporary Malaysian Literature by examining the selected writings
of new emerging voices in Malaysian Literature in English. In addition,
selected contemporary Malaysian theatres, collection of essays
and public opinion will be also discussed in passing. Many regard
Malaysia to be a homophobic place and generally queers are denied
freedom to express both sexual relations and self-determination
as well as intimacy. In other words, queering in Malaysia is still
very much ‘trapped’ in its cocoon of social and religious
taboo, yet it is now frantically squeezing its way through so as
to enable the process of queerness to ‘come out’. Therefore,
there is mounting pressure to voice queerness in Malaysia, hence,
creating awkwardness in expression. However, no matter how awkward
it may appear, voices of queerness that were then groping in the
dark are now seen traversing and breaking through boundaries. In
its efforts to ‘come out and play’, queerness in the
21st century of Malaysia starts cha(lle)nging awkwardness and oddity.
This paper also attempts to look at how queerness and queering
are put across in this new millennium, with regard to Malaysian
context, as they can take various forms of expression including
political satire and social critique. An assessment is also made
of the shifting and evolving trends in socio-economic political
and cultural perceptions, vis-à-vis the sliding and fluid
identity of the urban coming community of Malaysia.
Robert Don Adams, Florida Atlantic University
Sons and Lovers: Gay Saigon
I propose to utilize a creative non-fiction and literary critical viewpoint to
consider the life of gay men in Saigon (Ho Chi Minh City), as observed and experienced
by me during my two years of living there as a visiting Fulbright Professor of
American Literature and Culture (2002-04). I will draw upon a creative non-fiction
essay already written titled "Sons and Lovers," and will also examine
a recently published and translated novel, "A World Without Women," which
is the first contemporary fictional work in Vietnam dealing with the life of
gay men in Vietnamese society. I have discussed my proposal with Dr. Donn Colby,
who will include it in a panel he is coordinating concerning homosexuality in
Vietnamese society and culture.
Edgar Atadero, Progressive Organization of Gays in the Philippines
A Transgender Health Research Project in Manila
This presentation focuses on transgenderism, discrimination and effects on the
health situation of transgenders. It reports a Pro-Gay survey of attitudes, health
practices, beliefs and world views of Filipino transgenders (and a comparative
survey of modern gay-identified males) in some communities in the area called
Metro Manila. The survey aims to draw the connections between the two-way reactions
of Filipino transgenders to and with their surrounding environments on one hand
and the evolution of how transgenders form their indigenous world view about
sexuality, gender and health practices.
Gary Atkins, Seattle University
Encountering Babylon: Pursuing Beauty & Sexual Justice at a Globalized Gay
Sauna
Gay bathhouses, Allan Berube once noted, were among the first American institutions
to give that country’s gay men pride in themselves and in their sexuality
by creating a ‘safety zone’ where they could communicate and be affectionate
with each other. Today in Southeast Asia, one such bathhouse stands out in its
reputation as a place of contact and communication among gay Asian men from throughout
the region, as well as among Euro-American men. This journalistic paper examines
the history and role within Southeast Asia of what has become one of the world’s
best known gay bathhouses, Babylon. Relying on interviews, writings from those
who have visited, newspaper accounts, and observations, it traces the sauna’s
history from its inception at private social gatherings in the 1980s to the police
raids conducted in 2002 as part of a Thai government social crackdown. The paper
also profiles the gay Thai man who “authored” Babylon and examines
his approach to constructing a gay and male space through the communication elements
embedded in the sauna.
Chandra Shekhar Balachandran, The Dharani Trust, Bangalore, India
“
We don't do data, we only do action-based work.” - Why NGOs Need Data Capacity
and How to Provide it to Them.
Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) often work with resource limitations (trained
personnel, computing resources, analytical tools) that can prevent effective
gathering, interpretation and use of data in their programs. Further, there is
also a widely prevalent misconception that doing field work is somehow more important
than data collection, while in reality the two should be inseparable, because
data can (a) help set and guide the direction of field-work, (b) help determine
effectiveness of field work, and (c) allow results to be disseminated in a manner
that can be widely understood. This paper surveys a broad range of issues surrounding
data needs and challenges in the NGO sector dealing with HIV/AIDS and STD/STI
intervention and service work in India. Data gathered by NGOs in India are often
plagued with problems such as incomplete data, inadequate or faulty sampling,
and haphazard recording. While some of these problems are due to constraints
of field work, others are due to misunderstanding or inadequate training on data
collection, whether of quantitative or qualitative data. These hinder data use
in the sector as a whole. The types of data that NGOs invariably generate are
too often not even recognized as data, much less used as data. Shared data and
shared resources can greatly help resource-strapped NGOs develop robust data
infrastructure to better deliver their services to their beneficiaries. The Dharani
Trust has undertaken a collaborative initiative called DataMatters (www.dharanitrust.org/datamatters/)
with SAATHII (a HIV/AIDS NGO) and Servelots Infotech (P) Ltd. (a software company)
to develop a sustainable data capacity building endeavour. The paper will conclude
with a description of the broad contours of this initiative.
Robert Baldwin, Asia Pacific Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS, Bangkok
MSM Positive Prevention: Role of Males Who Have Sex With Males Living with HIV/AIDS
in HIV Prevention
Males who have sex with males (msm) living with HIV/AIDS (MSMLWHA) have a unique
and vital role to play in preventing the spread of HIV in our region. Although
recent research in Bangkok has indicated posssible high levels of HIV among local
msm there is a lack of relevant research in this area. Positive msm could be
said to be largely invisible. This closed door session for HIV+ msm, facilitated
by APN+ (Asia Pacific Network of PLWHA), will provide an opportunity for positive
msm to identify & discuss the issues of living with HIV/AIDS in the Asia
Pacific Region and their role in preventing the further spread of HIV. The results
of this workshop will be reported back to the larger conference.
Bidisha Banerjee, Independent Scholar
Creating a Lesbian Utopia: Reading the Queer Subtext of Mira Nair’s India
Cabaret
India Cabaret is Mira Nair’s documentary about the lives of cabaret dancers
and prostitutes at a seedy nightclub called Meghraj in Bombay. In my analysis
I wish to focus on the queer subtext of the film and demonstrate the working
class woman’s body as the site for resistance to patriarchy, class oppression
and heterosexuality. While heterosexuality is constantly at the forefront of
the women’s lives, I suggest that the homoerotic bond that even tends to
the homosexual between the women, allows them to escape the tawdriness of their
lives to a large extent and to seek comfort and a safe haven in each other’s
company. The women’s bodies thus function in two very different ways as
spectacularized objects during the dance scenes and as mediums of conveying homoerotic
desire in the scenes depicting the women interacting with each other. While the
former is strictly performative and an act, the latter is more meaningful and
gives them a sense of community and belonging that is denied them in their daily
lives due to the harsh ostracism faced by the women in society. Through the dual
function of the body as represented in the film, I want to posit a new feminist
framework which accounts for a corresponding duality in their experience that
portrays them as both exploited and having a certain agency. I thus problematize
the simple binarism of exploited victim and liberated woman as theorized in both
radical and pro-sex feminist paradigms.
Edgar Bauer, Independent Scholar
Magnus Hirschfeld: ‘Panhumanism’ and the Sexual Cultures of Asia
Magnus Hirschfeld (1868–1935) was the most prominent figure of the sexual
emancipation movement of his time and arguably the first queer theorist avant
la lettre. His scientifically most significant contribution was the ‘doctrine
of sexual intermediaries’ (Zwischenstufenlehre), according to which all
human beings are intersexual variants, i.e. composites in different and irrepeatable
proportions of both the masculine and the feminine sexual poles that as such
have no real existence. Since the proportions combining the two poles vary from
one another at the different descriptive levels and can alter or be altered in
time, Hirschfeld’s ‘doctrine’ purports the dissolution of sexual
categories that subsume individuals into pre-established sexes or genders. Against
the background of his emancipatory and sexological work, the paper examines Hirschfeld’s
assessment of the diversity of sexual conceptualisations in Asia as depicted
in his book Die Weltreise eines Sexualforschers, that was published in 1933 and
constitutes one of the most important documents of the nascent sexual ethnology.
The book is a report of the trip around the world he decided to undertake while
lecturing in America in 1930/1931, and that enabled him to have a first-hand
experience of the sexual cultures in Japan, China, the Philippines, Java, India,
Egypt, Palestine and Syria. During this trip, Hirschfeld attained a deeper understanding
of his own Jewishness and developed a more comprehensive view of the ‘panhumanism
and cosmopolitanism’ he had always strived for.
Ronald Baytan, De La Salle University
Redefining Man: Homo- and Hetero/sexualities in Philippine Cinema
Feminism and gay activism have radically changed the landscape of desire and
the nature of sexual identity in the Philippines, and we can see this phenomenon
very clearly in the movies. Now more than ever, the dichotomy lalake/bakla (roughly
translated: heterosexual/homosexual man) is ever becoming unstable. What constitutes
a lalake identity? How have the Filipino films in the last twenty years redefined
the lalake in relation to the bakla? This paper intends to explore these questions
through a reading of selected Filipino films from 1980 to 2004, namely: Manila
by Night (City after Dark, 1980), Macho Dancer (1988), Ang Lalake sa Buhay ni
Selya (1998), Sa Paraiso ni Efren (1999) and Liberated 2 (2004). I intend to
show how the said films have deconstructed the lalake/bakla dichotomy, how the
concept of being a ‘man’ (lalake) is redefined from the optic lens
of homosexuality, and how Filipino filmmakers have interrogated the bonds between
the bakla and his lalake and between the lalake and his lalake friend. This study
is part of a larger project that seeks to explore the relationship between gayness
and cinema in the Philippines in the last twenty-five years.
Anne Beaumont-Vernon, University of Essex
The Road to Transition: Transgender in Britain and in Thailand
This paper forms an integral part of my PhD thesis, which is a cross-cultural
comparative analysis of the transitioning process of male-to-female transsexuals
in Britain and kathoey in Thailand. In this paper I explore the various stages
that the typical British TS experiences on the road to transition, as compared
to the more easily facilitated transition of the kathoey in Thailand. Characteristically,
the British transsexual women in this study reported having felt ‘different’ from
a very early age, and by some chance or serendipity, discover that they fit the
popular description of ‘a woman trapped inside a man’s body’.
The discovery of transsexualism can be itself typically so traumatic or distressing
that the individual will either decide to try and ignore the problem, or suffer
in silence in the hope that it will ‘go away’. This means that the
transsexual individual in Britain is commonly physically fully matured long before
they seek help. The experience of the Thai kathoey is in striking contrast with
that of the British TS.
Chris Berry, Goldsmiths College
The Wedding Banquet Effect: Gay = Modern in Asian Cinema?
The global box office success of The Wedding Banquet has inspired a host of follow-up
films, and it has been claimed as the founding film for the trend known as Queer
or Gay Asian Cinema. Examples of films in The Wedding Banquet mode include the
recent Rainbow from Thailand and Arisan from Indonesia, as well as the earlier
Broken Branches from Korea and various Japanese films including Okoge and Twinkle.
It has not escaped the attention of critics that not only do these films display
upper middle class lifestyles but also that they represent a post-Stonewall Euro-American
model of gay identity. This takes the argument one step further by noting that
these two tropes are combined to produce a more distinctive rhetorical effect
in the context of East and Southeast Asian metropolitan participation in globalized
modernity. A post-Stonewall gay identity does not just occupy the same social
and textual space as globalized modernity in these films but also actually signifies
the ability to accept a post-Stonewall gay identity on the part of others and
sustain a gay lifestyle on the part of the protagonists signifies the attainment
of the globalized modernity so desired by the ruling classes and their adherents
in metropolitan East and Southeast Asia. Ironically, this confirms the derogatory
stereotypes displayed in commercial mass cinema, at the same time as it may be
a powerful rhetorical tool for placing leverage upon the ruling classes.
Kiran Bhairannavar, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi
Sexuality and the Politics of Space: A Study of Gays in New Delhi City of India
Space is a basic entity for expression of one's sexuality. A strong Patriarchal
set up and a skewed construction of Masculinity in the Indian social set up makes
space highly heterosexualised one. However amidst this heteronormative patriarchal
set up there have been and there are sexual minorities - Gays, Lesbians, Kothis,
Giriyas, Hijras, Bisexuals, Transgendered (about five million of them!), who
continue to face discrimination, stigma and harassment from their straight counterparts.
Moreover article 377 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) criminalizes homosexuality, making
things worse. My paper, through 20 conversational interviews of Gay men in New
Delhi, explores the interrelationship between space and homosexuality. It tends
to find out how objective space is snatched away from this invisible community
thus obstructing the creation of social spaces. Examining the politics of space
and identity, it tends to explore the role of organizations and groups in creating
safe spaces for the community. The paper looks into how Spaces of home, workplace,
public spaces and society at large are appropriated and controlled by the heterosexual
majority thus marginalizing gays to suffering, discrimination and harassment.
It also examines the role of Article 377 IPC in aggravating the situation and
issues of citizenship. Further it looks into the role of Cyber Revolution and
the efforts of various advocacy, support, and human rights groups, and their
(political) struggle in creating safe spaces for gays thus bringing a ray of
hope to reduce the plight of this Community in the capital city of India.
Maylei Blackwell – Paper title to be confirmed.
Mark Blasius, University of NY
Sexual Relationships and their Political Recognition in an Intercultural Context.
This roundtable will consist of a number of brief written contributions by its
members toward the goals of: a) analyzing the distinctive lgbtq partnership issues
within the cultures from which the participants come or in which they live; b)
making some cross-cultural comparisons—drawing parallels, pointing out
divergences, and suggesting theoretical generalizations—based upon these
issues and the cultural and legal problems that arise from them; and c) addressing
some international questions that arise from recognition or lack thereof for
lgbtq partnerships, for example, with respect to human rights law, immigration
and choice of co-residence (taking into account the socio-economic status of
the partners and the heteronormative ideologies of cultures), etc. With the participation
of the audience, a cross-cultural dialogue will emerge, placing cultural specificity
in the Asian region at the center, but taking into account global Asian diasporas,
and the non-Asian partners of Asian lgbtq’s. It is intended that the roundtable
will generate a number of co-authored and single authored papers, articles, or
book chapters.
Tom Boellstorff, University of California
Geographies of Belonging: Spatial Scale, Queer Subjectivities, Queer Rights
Because they are embodied, sexuality and gender are often represented as highly
local phenomena. Yet like other aspects of culture, sexuality and gender can
be produced through multiple spatial scales. In this talk, I draw from research
in Indonesia to examine how sexuality and gender are produced though translocal
(in particular, national and global) spatial scales. I discuss some methodological
and theoretical challenges encountered when studying the translocal production
of sexuality and gender. I explore how such translocal regimes of sexuality and
gender shape subjectivities and communities, and the implications of translocal
regimes of sexuality and gender with regard to rights, tolerance, and affirmation.
The talk will focus on how queer sexual and gendered subjectivities enter debates
over national belonging when such subjectivities are seen as ‘modern’ and
thus distinct from ‘traditional’ or ‘local’ conceptions
of gender and sexuality.
Carolyn Brewer, Murdoch University
Online Publication: The Experience of Intersections
Intersections: Gender, History and Culture in an Asian Context is a refereed
electronic journal conceived as an interactive forum for research and teaching
in the area of Gender Studies in the Asian region. Placed at the junction of
historical and contemporary concerns, Intersections emphasises the paramount
importance of research into the region’s multiple historical and cultural
gender patterns—patterns which are crucial for the understanding of contemporary
globalised societies, where identities and social relations are constantly being
negotiated against the background of dominant narratives. In this sense the journal
crosses disciplinary, cultural and gender boundaries. At the same time, Intersections
is intended as a means to explore innovative ways of presenting research using
new technologies. As such Information Technology is not seen as an end in itself,
but as a place where oral, written and visual history can tangibly cross paths
allowing for new connections to be made. Ten issues of the journal have now been
published and it is timely that some of the positive and negative aspects of
the online publication of such a journal are analysed. My paper will explore
the positives and negatives involved in the web-based publication of Intersections.
I will discuss issues associated with the design and publication of the journal
as well as exploring intellectual property rights and copyright issues associated
with a journal that has international exposure.
Denis Byrne, Dept of Environment and Conservation (NSW)
Mapping Queer Heritage
What archaeological, architectural or other physical traces of the history of
homosexuality might survive in the Asian landscape and should we do anything
about recording or conserving them? These ‘traces’ might include ‘traditional’ meeting/cruising
places, historic venues, the dwellings of notable authors, activists or other
personalities. This paper takes a preliminary look at what queer Asian cultural
heritage might look like and how it might be included in the cultural heritage
conservation framework that already operates in the region.
The tendency of 20th century Asian governments to deny that homosexuality is
indigenous to their culture, rather than a decadent Western import, is reflected
in the invisibility of homosexuality as a theme in heritage recording. The low
profile or underground nature of homosexuality in the 20th century may mean that
its heritage traces are ephemeral in nature and difficult to map in the urban
and rural landscape. However, a new interest in ‘intangibility’ in
the field of heritage studies internationally, and a growing recognition of the
heritage of minority cultures and marginalised or oppressed groups, may make
this a good moment to begin to record queer heritage in Asia.
Erma Eugenia Capucion, Women Supporting Women Centre, Quezon City, Philippines
When Images Talk: A Question of Lesbian Aesthetics
It is expected that everyone has realized that the visual arts is one form of
language, communication and in a deeper sense a form of discourse or discussion.
In the contemporary view of art, its presentation or curatorship provides enhanced
if not additional meaning to the creations, meaning that may go beyond or even
extend beyond the intentions of the artist. Furthermore, additional meanings
are formed by the audience who each have different perspectives and views of
the work of art that is informed by their own personal experiences and opinions.
In my research work for my masters thesis, the question frequently came up about
the validity of the lesbian as subject in the visual arts. I received very strong
arguments that if my work as a lesbian artist contain this subject then it becomes
propaganda. But no arguments were made about propaganda versus art. The problems
that an art practitioner faces are multi-layered when one uses the label, lesbian
artist. As it is, art as a discourse is already laden with controversial debates,
and it becomes more complicated when the label lesbian is thrown into it especially
in a country like the Philippines. This paper will not provide a ready answer,
but will instead aim to present research materials, quote references, point out
cross-references of established academicians, critics, and artists, to support
the argument for a lesbian aesthetic.
James Caspian, University of Westminster
Transgender in the People’s Republic of China
I will discuss the situation of transgendered people in China with particular
reference to: estimated numbers of operations; the attitude of Chinese culture
towards TG people, including religion, family and cultural mores; TG people and
employment; civil rights and the legal situation, e.g. ability to live in their
new gender role, right to marry, legal status, right to change gender on identity
documents; access and affordability of medical services; support; attitudes in
the media; TG networks and what doctors and TG people themselves have to say
about the current situation. Chak Lui Chan, Chinese University HK
‘
Interesting’ Gender-Crossing: A Case of Cantonese Opera in Hong Kong
‘
Faan-Chuen’ is known as gender-crossing in the public understanding of
Cantonese Opera. The performers can explicitly ‘do gender’ on-stage
which subverts the stability and naturalized myth of gender identities. However,
the reading of those Faan-Chuen performers (‘male female impersonator’ and ‘female
male impersonator’) is always to subtly re-stabilize their ‘natural
sex’ while emphasize their ‘crossing’. In this article, I will
use a TV program about a famous Faan-Chuen male impersonator Yam Kim-Fai to question
the representation/reading of s/he in the TV program. Why is Faan Chuen so ‘interesting’?
How can the public take the pleasure (it can be erotic) and keep on placing the
act of gender-crossing as Other?
Connie Man Wai Chan, Women’s Coalition of HKSAR
Survey on Discrimination on the Grounds of Sexual Orientation for Women in Hong
Kong
This is a very crucible moment for every LGBT in Hong Kong, because the Hong
Kong Government is going to conduct a review on its policy dealing with the problem
of discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation! Measures are emerging
to protect women from sexual orientation discrimination in Hong Kong. Although
women are now enjoying an umbrella of the Sex Discrimination Ordinance, there
is no law that specifically outlaws discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation.
Women Coalition of HKSAR (WC) conducts initial research into the nature and extent
of sexual orientation discrimination in Hong Kong. The central purpose of this
report is to call attention to the extent of sexual orientation discrimination
in Hong Kong, and to increase the awareness of those actors who can most effectively
combat such discrimination, concerns about discriminatory behaviors in the police
force, in the health service, and in the business and education environment,
in the family and in the public areas.
Kenneth Chan, Nanyang Technological University
Rice Sticking Together: Desire and the Cinematic Representation of Caucasian-Chinese
Relationships
This paper examines the narrative structure and cultural rhetoric of contemporary
diasporic Chinese cinema that deals specifically with gay interracial relationships
between Chinese and Caucasian men, a form of what some would call the ‘rice-and-potato’ relationship.
By examining films from Hong Kong, the United States, Australia, and Britain,
I would argue that these films, in seeking to reject the Madame Butterfly power
dynamic, move toward a cultural nationalist ideological argument. This is particularly
evident, for instance, in the narrative progression of documentaries, like Banana
Queer and Rice and Potatoes, professing to offer insight into this social phenomenon;
or in narrative shorts, such as Yellow Fever and Fall 1990, that espouse to highlight
the racial discrimination of the diasporic Chinese minority even within gay communities.
However, though this argument has its political place, the fluid and complex
notion of desire, in spite of its historicity, confounds and disturbs this identity
politics by queerly resisting its rhetorical insistence. A number of more recent
films from the U.S. register a kind of utopian possibility that, despite its
idealism, present a paradigm of desire that negotiates the racism and stereotyping
faced by gay Chinese minorities in Western nations, without negating the presence
and hope of this desire.
Kit Sze Amy Chan, Hong Kong Shue Yan College
On the Edge of Culture: Sex and Sexualities in Taiwan and Hong Kong Science Fiction
Modern science fiction frequently involves themes of sex, gender and sexuality.
It is no coincidence that science fiction has always been the site for gay, lesbian
and queer voices. Ursula Le Guin’s The Left Hand of Darkness, Joanna Russ’s
Female Man and Mary Percy’s He, She, It are most well-known Sci-Fi novels
that deal with ideas like androgyny, third-sex, homosexuality or even trans-species
sexualities. One of the most important characteristics of science fiction as
a literary genre is that it enables its authors and readers to explore not only
the world and human beings as they are, but also as they could have been in the
other time-space or might be in a futuristic setting. The focus of this paper
is to argue that both being on the margin of mainstream culture, queer theory
and science fiction perhaps can make a perfect couple in fighting against the
patriarchal, heterosexual society. This paper will discuss the sex and sexualities
in Hong Kong and Taiwan Science Fiction along with the development of gay, lesbian
and queer movement Authors discussed include: Chi Ta-wei, and Lucifer Hung from
Taiwan and Tam Chien from Hong Kong.
Vinay Chandran, Swabhava Trust, Bangalore, India
“
It's not my job to tell you, it's okay to be gay”: Medicalisation of Homosexuality
The homosexual in India is studied as a criminal in legal discourse, a sick person
in medical discourse and a sinner in religious discourse. These three systems
of knowledge have had had a far-reaching impact in the attempts to understand
who the homosexual is in contemporary India. This paper traces the emergence
of the homosexual in medical categories in the west and looks at how that western
category has been uncritically accepted as a part of the discourse of the Indian
mental health profession. It examines the definitions of homosexuality in the
Indian context and how the worldview of the mental health professional in India
is formed at the intersections of the discourses of law, medicine and religion
and how that worldview finds expression in 'treating homosexuals.' Finally it
looks at how this worldview, which medicalises the homosexual, is being questioned
by the emergence of the discourse of queer rights. The effort has been to trace
out the categories right from their origin in western medical discourse to their
deployment in contemporary Indian settings. In addition, for the purpose of understanding
the contemporary 'meaning' attached to homosexuality, the paper looks at empirical
data gathered from interviewing clinical psychologists, psychiatrists, sexologists,
and counsellors with a view to ascertaining medical responses to homosexuality.
The paper specifically looks at the allopathic medical system because of the
number of homosexuals who have been 'treated' for their homosexuality by professionals
in the mental health field.
Hong-cheng Maurice Chang, University of Milan
“
Made in Taiwan: Gay Rights of the Western Body with Oriental Soul”
Last October, it was reported that the Taiwan Government was preparing legislation
to legitimize gay marriage. If the new law is passed it would make Taiwan the
first country in Asia to recognize marriages between people of the same sex.
This presentation gives a brief view on gay rights developments and a clear picture
on the proposal to recognize same-sex relationships in Taiwan. During the discussion
it will be explained that the proposal is a "solemn proclamation," or
even a political slogan. It will also be discussed how Asian societies, more
specifically the Chinese societies, integrate the idea of same-sex marriage with
the traditional family system and the stigma of not having offspring and legal
strategies for gay rights movement in Taiwan.
Pei-Jean Chen, National Chiao-Tung University
‘
Queer’ that Matters -What is Queer Culture in Taiwan?
This paper is an analysis of the term ‘queer’ in Taiwan, which’s
phonetic Mandarin transliteration is ku‚er;. I will explore the genealogy
and deployment of the term ku‚er in the Taiwanese context, examining its
use in social discourse and in cultural representation and artistic creation.
During the early-to-mid 1990s, lesbian and gay student associations mushroomed
on university campuses all over Taiwan, and some lesbian and gay studies courses
began to be taught in the major universities. Out of this emergent lesbian and
gay academic culture came the localized translation of the 1990s English reclamation
of ‘queer.’ ‘Queer’ was first time transliterated as
the Chinese word ‘ku’er’ in the magazine ‘Isle Margin’ by
Chi Ta-Wei and other scholars in 1994.1. Before the transliteration, ‘queer’ has
been translated to another Chinese word and showed up in some researches and
discourses. When ‘queer’ was transliterated to ku’er, the term’s
insistence and intention in some way has been changed through the translation/transliteration.
All discussions and annotations of the word enrich its meaning and definition
in Taiwanese context. So, the paper will work on how is the word ‘queer/ku’er
becomes a genre and represent in the academic field, social discourse, artistic
works, and subculture.
Yu-Xin Chen, National Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan
Passionate Friendship: Schoolgirl Romance and Female Homosexuality in May Fourth
Era China
This essay argues that homoerotic schoolgirl romance in the May Fourth China
compellingly testifies to the tension between the publican intellectuals‚ expectant
experience of Westernization and anxious wrestling with given mechanisms of surveillance
on women‚s intimate relationships. As metropolitan theorization of sexology
flooded into intellectual debates, the concept of homosexuality was keenly translated
and discussed. Unlike mostly Euro-American sexologists that categorized women
with same-sex desires with fixed (homo) sexual identity, Chinese intellectuals
tended to view women‚s same-sex desires as temporary and situational. As
Liberal New Women writers illustrated juvenile intrafemale liaisons as painful
processes of self-discovery with catastrophic ending due to social pressures,
it can be observed that the structure of local homophobic hegemony was emerging.
The second half of the essay focuses on western-styled boarding school for girls,
a seemingly liberating modern institution that oftentimes occasions such tension.
Whereas the school enables girls to realize and express their affections and
desires for other girls, it is entrenched by disciplines brought by Christian
church and undercurrents of homophobic discourses developed in the local community.
Along with several other pieces of proto-T/po schoolgirl romance, Eileen Chang’s
Tongxue shaonian do buqian (My Prosperous Classmates) is read, in particular,
as a telling example of enduring feelings between westernized female intellectuals,
happily within and poignantly without the sheltering world of boarding school.
The boarding school in May Fourth Era, in sum, revealingly saw the dynamic interaction
between local and western forms of suppression of women’s dissident sexualities.
Song Pae Cho, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Playing in the Dark: Korean "Gay" Men and "Gay" Korean Bathhouses
Gay experience and urban modernity are uniquely intertwined, with the latter
providing the staging ground for sexual experimentation and openness in ways
that permit a kind of emergent gay democracy. Within the urban setting, gay men
have had the opportunity to meet other men and create social practices and institutions
that constitute the “gay experience.” Among these varied practices
has been the practice of “public” sex, queering the often marginalized
and abjected spaces of urban settings such as deserted lots, parks, and public
bathrooms into a stage for sexual encounters and connections between men. Even
though the mainstream gay and lesbian movement in South Korea has often disparaged
these spaces in favour of more “formal” rights and markers of “gay
citizenship,” in this paper, I argue that it is, in fact, the “wild” and “unregulated” spaces
that often exist only provisionally and both within as well as outside the field
of gay commodification, that we can see the practices of gay democracy and public
gay society-making. Using ethnography from “gay” bathhouses in Seoul,
Korea, I argue that these spaces where queer desire sometimes takes us by surprise
can open ourselves up to the pleasure of inter-class and inter-generational contact
as well as the possibility of imagining other forms of sociality. However, they
can also reveal the limits of Western notions of “gay identity,” and “gay
community.”
Wei-cheng Chu, National Taiwan University
Queer(ing) Taiwan and Its Future: From an Agenda of Mainstream Self-Enlightenment
to One of Sexual Citizenship?’
I offer here first and foremost a glocal analysis of the noteworthy emergence
of a lesbian and gay (or in local terms, tongzhi) movement in the 1990s Taiwan.
Taiwan’s example may strike as particularly intriguing in the mainstream
prominence enjoyed by the cultural representations of tongzhi and the coverage
of tongzhi issues. My theory is that the emergence of Taiwan’s tongzhi
movement at that historical conjuncture, and the specific form it has taken,
in effect depends upon what I call a ‘self-enlightening’ agenda pursued
by the mainstream Taiwanese society since the democratization process starting
in the late 1980s. That is why the gradual halt of this agenda in the late 1990s
also coincides with the cooling-off of the movement, as its prosperity had been
very much a mainstream media effect and the mainstream attention to tongzhi issues
was then apparently on the wane. As if to further prove this, certain contingent
developments in the mainstream politics since 2000 has given a new spur to the
movement by inducing what can be called a ‘civic turn’ of it, as
issues of (minority) citizenship and civil rights for tongzhi are now openly
on the agenda. I will also examine this most recent development with the purpose
of showing the local limitations of this largely imported discourse as well as
arguing for its possible significance in terms of local political future which
now centers on a zest for ethno-nationalism.
Hang Kuen Chua, Universiti Sains Malaysia
The History of the Lesbian, Gay & Trans-sexual Communities in Malaysia
Homosexuality has been a feature of Malaysian society. The written record of
male homosexuality in Malaysia can be traced back to as early as the British
colonial period. Despite the social and legal barriers that have been put up
by the British and the present sovereign state, the homosexual/gay/queer subcultures
manifest themselves under the multiple influences of industrialization, urbanization,
and globalisation within the diverse local socio-cultural and repressive political
environment over the years. This paper explores the characteristics, organizations,
movements as well as discourses of these subcultures throughout the course of
their development. The PT Foundation (formally known as Pink Triangle) and other
virtual groups will be specifically referred to in the discussion of the contemporary
gay/queer subcultures in Malaysia. This paper will also discuss the relationship
among the gay/queer and transsexual and lesbian communities, with specific reference
to transsexualism in Malaysian society. The impact of the HIV/AIDS epidemic on
these perceived high-risk groups in Malaysia will also be covered.
Donn Colby, Harvard University
Using Social Networks to Reach MSM for HIV Prevention in Vietnam
Background: Research has shown that Men who have Sex with Men (MSM) in Vietnam
have a high risk for HIV infection. There are now HIV prevention projects specifically
targeting MSM in 2 cities in Vietnam, with more planned in the near future. Methods:
40 in-depth interviews and 3 focus group discussions were held with self-identified
MSM in Ho Chi Minh City (HCMC), Vietnam, in early 2004. The information gathered
was used to help develop a peer-educator based HIV prevention program. Results:
MSM in HCMC can be categorized into two broad groups: bong kin and bong lo. Bong
kin are outwardly masculine and due to social stigma often hide their sexual
orientation. Bong lo assume a feminine gender; wearing female clothing, jewellery,
and make-up, and using feminine mannerisms. Both socialize mostly within their
own group. Bong Kin usually have other bong kin as sexual partners, while the
sexual partners of bong lo are usually heterosexually-identified men. Both group
engage in risky sexual behavior, such as unprotected anal sex or oral sex with
ejaculation; and hold many misconceptions about their risk of HIV and STDs. Water-based
lubricants are rarely used. Bong lo often face discrimination in society, such
as not being allowed entrance to entertainment establishments and difficulty
in finding a job.
Conclusions Peer educators can use social networks to contact and provide educational
materials to MSM. Better knowledge about and access to water based lubricants
are needed. Many MSM still face discrimination.
Nerida Cook, University of Tasmania
Public Perceptions of Tom and Dee in Thailand
There are now a number of highly informative studies of the experiences and self-identities
of tom and dee in Thailand, as well as of characterisations of tom, dee, kathoey
and gays in the public domain, such as in various media and in academia. However
there is still little systematic work on how members of the general Thai public
perceive and understand tom and dee, gay and kathoey individuals. This paper
presents findings from focus group interviews conducted in Bangkok in the mid-1990s
to begin to fill this lacuna. The focus group study explored both how these various
categories (tom, dee, gay, kathoey) are constructed in the public imagination,
and how focus group participants sought explanations for these non-normative
sex-gender identities in relation to their views of contemporary Thai society.
The focus group findings on tom and dee will be presented and briefly compared
with the views of tom and dee themselves (collected at the same time) in order
to explore commonalities and differences between ‘outsider’ and ‘insider’ constructions.
The comparison aims to develop preliminary data on the degree to which public
discourses are appropriated by, contributed to, or shared by tom and dee; and
ways the public perceptions fall short of the latter’s understandings.
The broader purpose is to examine the everyday perceptions, both sympathetic
and prejudicial, that tom and dee face on a daily basis, since everyday interactions
are highly significant in the ability of tom and dee to exercise choices regarding
self expression and lifestyle options.
Rebecca Lynn Cross, University of Texas
Gloria Anzaldua
Radical Chicana lesbian feminist Gloria Anzaldúa wrote extensively about
La Frontera, the borderlands, and the transient and permanent residents of those
areas. She described the ambiguous, unsettled space between the borders as nepantla,
and those who guide others through that spatial chaos as nepantleras. At their
best, transgendered people make ideal nepantleras because they all qualify as ‘wounded
healers’, or those whose past or on-going experience makes them particularly
empathetic to others entering nepantla. Anzaldúa described the process
of passing through nepantla as acquiring conocimiento, a consciousness rooted
in self-awareness and wholeness, often found in indigenous traditions. In this
regard, she qualifies as curandera, or people’s healer. By practicing conocimiento,
transgendered people find healing for themselves as well as become healer/guides
for others, both straight and transgendered, thus becoming cultural resources,
as opposed to social anomalies.
Glenn Cruz, The Library Foundation, Manila, The Philippines
Promoting Health among Men who have Sex with Men Through Affirming Diverse Sexuality
and Community
The Library Foundation (TLF) is committed to prevention of sexually transmitted
infections among men having sex with men (MSM), including HIV. In 2002, with
help from International HIV/AIDS Alliance, TLF conducted peer outreach education
to 200 gay and bisexual men in Metro Manila through the Healthy Interaction and
Values Workshops - full-day seminars on sexuality and sexual health. Designed
to be participatory, the workshop determined dynamics of sexual networking in
MSM venues, facilitated improvement of risk awareness to STI/HIV, raise issues
on self-esteem, sexuality comfort and community mutual support to enable individuals
towards safer sexual behaviour. But among those who participated, attending the
workshops generally was seen to be a resolve towards acknowledging one's sexuality.
While baseline knowledge was higher compared to other population sentinels, reported
safer sexual behaviour among MSM was generally lower. Divisiveness among different
sexual/gender expressions challenged efficient implementation of the project
but its immediate outcomes included improvement of attitudes towards one's own
and others' gender and sexual expressions.
Brian Curtin, Raffles LaSalle International Design School
Thailand’s Gay Male Sexual Cultures and the Problem of Visual Representation
This paper addresses the issue of Bangkok as a supposed paradise for gay men
by examining the visual imagery of internet and print advertisements produced
by male go-go bars and massage venues. I draw on Peter A. Jackson’s essay
Tolerant but Unaccepting: The Myth of a Thai ‘Gay Paradise’ but am
less concerned with foreign misconceptions of Thai social life than the semiotic
currency of this sexualized imagery, which I examine in terms of a dialectic
between the production of and resistance to forms of stereotyping. That is, the
forms of stereotyping which can inform the assumption of a paradis‚. Following
Jackson, the notion of paradise‚ is understood as the result of a purported
absence of homophobic restrictions and, further, the effect of orientalist interpretations
of Asian male sexualities and commercial sex. I trace the terms by which my examples
of visual imagery can be implicated in discursive processes of stereotyping and
demonstrate the multiple levels on which meaning can operate through context
and questions of desire, race and spectatorship. The aim of this paper is to
employ the visual image as a central means of marking and contesting knowledge
of ‘Thai’ sexual cultures.
Nikos Lexis Dacanay, University of the Philippines
Globalizing Gay Culture in Virtual Space: the Case of the Virtualized Gay Identity
My paper is about the virtualization of the everyday experience of the city and
how the expression of gay identity is implicated in the setup. I want to understand
the complex relationships between the influence of the global phenomenon of virtual
space to the internationalization of gay identity and the re-modification of
the concept of such an identity in the local understanding of sexuality. There
has been much talk about the internationalization of American-modeled gay lifestyle
and this would presume to indicate a globalization of modern gay identitiy. My
argument is that the operations of sex and gender in Thailand and Philippine
societies may be different from Western societies. The concept of gay identity
is redefined when we observe how homosexuals in both Thailand and the Philippines
live their lives in the seemingly virtualized gay spaces that in the cities.
I will look at gay identity and its complexities in the age of virtual spaces.
How has virtual space affected Thai and Filipino homosexuals' ways of living
a gay lifestyle? What are the ways by which gay-identified men define their sex/gender
against the backdrop of the globalization of the virtual, the incipient internationalization
of Western-modeled gay culture, and the particularistic histories of local sex/gender
order? My emphasis is the concept of global gay identity as a product of international
gay spaces in the Philippines and Thailand, and how this identity is being renegotiated
when Filipino and Thai homosexuals regard their local and traditional understanding
of gender and sexuality.
Peter Dankmeijer, Empowerment Lifestyle Services
Education on LGBT Issues in a Global Context: Opportunities in Asia
In 1997, during the Amsterdam Gay Games, Empowerment Lifestyle Services organized
an international workshop on LGBT education. The workshop took place in the context
of a cultural event organized by Amnesty International and was financed and supported
by HIVOS. Thanks to this, we were able to invite speakers from all over the world.
We expected education about LGBT issues to be quite different all over the world,
due to cultural, religious and political differences. So the participants were
very surprised to discover that—apart from obvious differences_we still
have a lot in common when providing education about LGBT issues. At the end of
the workshop, we concluded it would be useful to create a global network to facilitate
continuous exchange on LGBT education. Peter Dankmeijer started building this
in 2003-2004 by interviewing organizations around the world. The interviews were
meant as a needs assessment. A website (www.lgbt-education.info) was started
and will be developed into a platform for this network. In this presentation,
Dankmeijer will give an overview of the results of the needs assessment and will
suggest how specific Asian needs for education about LGBT issues are different
or similar to needs in other parts of the world. A discussion after this presentation
will focus on how transnational collaboration on educational campaigns and projects
can improve our work.
Romit Dasgupta, University of Western Australia
‘
Homosocial Desire’ versus ‘Heterosexual Hegemony’ in Corporate
Japan
The shift in research focus from lesbian and gay studies to an emphasis on ‘queer’ has
brought out questions about the ways in which everyday, ostensibly heteronormative
spaces and practices may in fact be inter-laced with dynamics of (usually un-acknowledged
and un-articulated) same-sex desire. One area which has been the focus of research
attention has been spaces of male-male homosocial bonding and interaction. As
work on institutions such as the military or sports clubs has revealed, a public
face of aggressive unambiguous heterosexuality may well have an underlying subtext
of what Sedgwick describes as ‘homosocial desire’.
Corporate organizations are good examples of spaces where outward hegemonic heteronormativity
may often be undergirded by what Michael Roper refers to as ‘circuits of
homosocial desire’. In the case of Japan, hegemonic corporate masculinity,
as embodied in the figure of the white-collar salaryman has been premised on
an ideology of the male as heterosexual husband and father. Yet, at the same
time, the success of this model of masculinity also depended heavily on the male
employee prioritizing homosocial attachment to his colleagues and the organization,
over heterosexual attachment to his family. Using material from interviews with
younger corporate sector employees, as well from popular culture texts, this
paper draws attention to the ways in which dynamics of ‘homosocial desire’ inform
the individual’s negotiations and engagements with corporate masculinity.
Carlos Decena, Center for Lesbian and Gay Studies
Towards Cross-Regional Dialogue: Perspectives from the Americas
(United States) will identify key issues in LGBTQ research in specific Latin
American countries and among Latino/as in the United States. Apart from providing
APQ Bangkok 2005 attendees with information about ongoing research and activism,
the panel will end with questions and topics to stimulate cross-regional dialogue
between scholars in the Asia/Pacific region and those working in the Americas.
Naifei Ding, Jen-Peng Liu & Amie Parry, National Central University, National
T’sing Hua University
Faking Gender: Violence and Baseness from 1970s Lesbian Pulp to 1990s Queer Gothic
Fiction’
Taiwan’s second upsurge of entertainment industries and sex cultures coincided
with the US military presence and backing for the post-49 KMT regime. These industries
and cultures are the setting for the emergence of representations of T-po (gendered
lesbian) relations and communities. By the 1970s, sensationalist media reportage
pathologized homosexuality, and medical discourse followed suit. This was part
of a larger state-driven campaign for moral tooling designed to discipline bodily
appearance just as sexual cultures were proliferating within the informal sectors
of the state economy. Our paper analyzes, firstly, the critical reception of
early lesbian and gay fiction in Taiwan. It then turns to how representations
of T-po bodies in 1970s melodrama struggle with institutionalized representational
forces while at the same time constructing new strategies that are in dialogue
with both state technologies and T-po lesbian communities and cultures. Lastly,
it looks at how some of those strategies from early pulp fiction, especially
their use of vampire imagery, are reconfigured in 1990s narratives that coincide
with the establishment of GLBT social movements.
Serge Doussantousse, Independent Researcher
A Gender Minority in Lao PDR: Transgenders or Kathoeys
Background: Lao PDR, a country bordering Thailand with comparable cultural traits.
One similarity shared by both countries is the number of visible transgenders,
called Kathoey. Although there is little research on Kathoey in Laos, it has
been observed that several Kathoey in Vientiane and Savannakhet have already
been infected with HIV. A feasibility study was conducted in Vientiane (Capital
of Lao PDR) and Savannakhet with a convenience sampling.
Methods: 11 self identified Kathoey were interviewed in Vientiane and Savannakhet
early 2004. The interviews used a semi-structured questionnaire and cover various
topics including sexual identity, sexual behaviour, HIV knowledge, demographic
factors, and perceptions about discrimination.
Findings: Contact with Kathoey is easy; Discrimination seems minimal in the society
and family. A growing number of Kathoey is involved in prostitution: they receive
money from their foreign partner/ clients but have to pay their Lao boy friends.
Their sexual practices are comparable to MSM's. Their knowledge on HIV transmission
is still limited. Homosexual and transgenders are two different groups with strong
sub-culture. Those men have chosen in their early teen to become the second women,
as they called themselves. They work in most of women activities: Hair-dresser,
restaurant, Entertainment facilities and seems well integrated in the Lao community.
Recommendations: The understanding of Kathoey's integration in Lao society help
at designing program targeting them. Kathoeys must participated at every level
of the research from planning to analysis.
Robyn Emerton, University of Hong Kong
Half Full or Half Empty? Legal Status and Activism of the Transgender Community
in Hong Kong
Gender reassignment surgery has taken place in Hong Kong since the mid 1980s,
and has always received public funding. At the administrative level, various
concessions are made towards post-operative transsexual persons, which undoubtedly
facilitate their every day lives. These include the reissue of identity cards,
passports and driving licences in their chosen gender. However, there is no means
for them – or for transgender persons more broadly – to change their
birth certificates. This denies them full legal recognition (including marriage)
in their chosen gender, and renders them vulnerable to prejudice and discrimination,
which is still sorely rife in Hong Kong. In some other countries in Asia, transgender
persons have successfully campaigned to claim their right to legal recognition,
using the courts and legislature to good effect. Examples to be discussed include
Singapore, Japan and the Philippines. By contrast – although the transgender
community is now achieving more visibility in Hong Kong and is slowly becoming
more politically active – the issue of legal recognition has never been
raised before Hong Kong’s courts or legislature. This paper will offer
some preliminary observations on why this may be the case – and also shed
some light on the paper’s title!
Elisabeth Engebretsen, London School of Economics & Political Science
Lesbian Identity and Community Making in Beijing: Towards a Queerer Type of Ethnography
LGBTQ communities cross-culturally are often understood to participate in a process
of gay globalization originating in Euro-American cultures. Local LGBTQ cultures
are accordingly adopting ‘Western’-based gay identity politics and
lifestyles, with the significance of local conditions remaining largely underestimated.
Another common approach emphasizes that contemporary LGBTQ cultures outside ‘Western’ locales
creatively adopt those global images of queer cultures that fit into existing
specific contexts, and discard those that do not. Based on ongoing fieldwork
among lesbian communities in Beijing, I discuss how lesbians make sense of the
global images of lesbian lifestyles and queer cultures now available to them
through new media and technology, to create a lesbian sense of community and
identity–collective and individual–and which ultimately takes a highly
China-specific context as its structural basis. I suggest that a more constructive
way of understanding LGBTQ community- and identity-making, now increasingly globalized
and imagined similarly across cultures, may be not by regarding what happens
in different locales as variations over a Euro-American originating gay cultural
project, but rather, by paying keen attention to the processes of how everyday
meanings and knowledges are continually created, re-created, contested and imagined
by lesbians in the specific locales in question, and on that basis attempt to
theorise the interconnections with global flows of gay cultures. I hope to contribute
towards debates about queer studies’ relevance in cross-cultural contexts,
and how we can best theorise identity politics and processual change in the age
of globalization.
John Erni, City University HK
Queer Pop Asia: Toward a Hybrid Regionalist Imaginary
Popular images of queers‚ in Asia are taking a number of specific forms,
which are in turn constituting new and significant (urban) contexts across the
region. These forms index particular kinds of queer desire for visibility. This
paper first briefly sketches the contour of queer popular culture in Asia, including
the specific academic and intellectual discourses built around it. It then explores
some important forms through which Asian queer‚ and pop‚ converge,
including the consistent, almost nonchalant, blurring of the line between homosociality
and homoeroticism, the performativity of drag as an open political allegory,
and the beautiful, often feminine, youth narratives. Moving out, around, and
rapidly, these cultural productions have a way of coalescing into syncretic queer
practices across Asia. The fertile historical and political ground of Taiwan
will be discussed as an important space of hybrid convergence at this moment.
Ross Forman, School of Oriental and African Studies
Catamite Coolies and Chinese Sodoms: British Investigations into Chinese Labourers‚ Sexuality
in the 19th & 20th Centuries
A common accusation levelled against Chinese labourers brought to various British
colonies at the end of the nineteenth century and the early twentieth century
was that they were undesirable because of their penchant for pederasty. From
sites as geographically disparate as Guiana and Malaya and South Africa, there
emerged a discourse about ‘catamite coolies’ that typed Chinese labourers
as problematic and promoted their repatriation over more usual patterns of settlement
at the end of their indentures. Often relying on testimony from missionaries
or other interested parties and often focusing on the role played by cross-dressing
troupes of Chinese actors (who were presumed to serve as male prostitutes), British
officials carried out a number of investigations into ‘unnatural vice’ in
mining compounds and plantation settings. These investigations yield important
historical information about colonial understandings of Asian sexualities and
patterns of sociability. This paper offers an overview of these inquiries, focusing
especially on the 1906 investigation into Chinese labourers in the Transvaal,
whose ramifications were so explosive that Winston Churchill actually uttered
the word ‘sodomy’ in Parliament. The paper considers what the moral
and political implications of Asian male-male sexuality in workers’ enclosures
were; what developmental theories of homosexuality were invoked (for instance,
the claim that working-class men from Northern China learned about sodomy by
sleeping in close proximity to one another during the cold winters); and how
the workers were and were not able to represent their subjectivities through
interpreters within the legalistic environment in which these colonial investigations
were conducted.
Rory Gallagher, Cambridge University
Shifting Markets, Shifting Risks: Male and Transgender Tourist-orientated Sex
Work in South-East Asia
HIV prevention policies and research in South-East Asia have focused predominantly
upon female, brothel-based; sex work. The rapidly growing male and transgender
tourist-orientated sex industry is characterized by more; forms of sex work (in
bars, nightclubs, massage parlours, restaurants and hotels for example), making
the mapping and definition of commercial especially problematic. Consequently
these economic, social, political, medical and imaginary geographies remain largely
unexplored by scholars and marginalized in HIV policies; lacunae that urgently
require attention. If appropriate HIV prevention programs are to be formulated,
a theoretical framework must be developed that can accommodate the burgeoning
numbers of male and female tourists who engage in sexual-economic exchanges with
male and transgender sex workers, and the complex interplay between the gendered,
raced and economic powers involved in these encounters.
This paper will draw upon primary fieldwork conducted in Phuket, Thailand and
Bali, Indonesia in order to analyze in which particular spatial, symbolic or
situational contexts unsafe sexual practices are most prevalent, and to identify
measures that can be taken to reduce the incidence of these risky sexual behaviours.
It concludes that HIV prevention policies must engage with the shifting intersections
between tourism, sex work, sexuality, sexual behaviour and sexual health in the
twenty-first century. Specifically, they must respond to the growing heterogeneity
of sex workers and tourists, and the variety of sexual-economic exchanges now
involved.
J. Neil C. Garcia, University of the Philippines
The Postcolonial Perverse: Hybridity, Desire, and the Nation in Federico Licsi
Espino, Jr’s Lumpen
Over the last century, literary renderings of the Filipino nation have invariably
been heterosexual and nativist. The national polity, as imagined by many Filipino
writers, typically excludes both the perverse and the culturally ‘impure’.
As a consequence, the vision of a national awakening such texts purvey essentializes
the postcolonial situation into the unworkable polarities of Self and Other.
The paper will examine the various ‘dissident’ spaces made available
by the inclusion of perversion and hybridity into the national imagination. The
world of Espino’s novella from 1985 is peopled by perverts and racial and/or
ideological half-breeds: hustlers, thieves, cross-dressers, hermaphrodites, closet
cases, and apparitional and racially ‘mongrelized’ characters. Their
erotic lives, colorful, complex and helplessly enmeshed, transpire in the midst
of political strife in the Philippine capital: student protests, marches, and ‘disappearances’ typical
of the period right before and during Martial Law rule. According to the novel,
the country’s official political economy is regularly challenged by its ‘underground’ economy
of desire, in which other struggles and agencies may be seen to exist. Here,
the downtrodden traffic in perverse gratification, both for material and erotic
ends. In this world, the disenfranchised are able to indulge their own desires
while reversing the customary order of things. As a postcolonial text, Lumpen
not only admits to the possibility of imagining a Filipino nation constituted
of cultural and political hybrids; it also gestures towards the idea of a nation
whose liberation lies in its embrace and celebration of the ‘impure’ and/or
the ‘perverse.’
Andrea Goh, Melissa Say, Gerald Tan, Frederick Tong, Nanyang Technological University
Probing Pink Porn: The perceived value of sexual content for homosexual and heterosexual
audiences
Singapore law requires consideration of the literary, artistic, social, cultural,
educational and scientific value of media content in deciding whether it is objectionable.
Responses to structured depth interviews with 40 adults aged over 30 (equal numbers
of homosexuals and heterosexuals) were analysed to determine the perceived value
of sexual content targeted at homosexual and heterosexual audiences. Input from
lawyers, media practitioners and members of the Media Authority’s various
committees was also analysed.
Gayatri Gopinath, University of California at Davis
“
Bollywood Spectacles: Queer Diasporic Critique in the Aftermath of September
11th”
In the years following the attacks of September 11th, 2001, South Asian racialization
in the U.S. has taken place through curious and contradictory processes. Even
as the “indefinite detentions” and deportations of Arabs, Muslims
and South Asians continued unabated, the last three years saw the veritable explosion
of interest in Bollywood cinema among non-South Asian audiences. How can we account
for this heightened visibility and “discovery” of Bollywood cinema,
at precisely the moment when South Asian communities in the U.S. are being more
intensely surveilled, policed and terrorized by the state than ever before? This
paper argues that the ubiquity and popularity of Bollywood outside of India at
this particular moment of U.S. imperialist aggression and global hegemony bears
close scrutiny, as it reveals a great deal about the complex interrelation of
multiple nationalisms and diasporic formations in the context of globalization.
In order to fully unpack these connections, I suggest the necessity of what we
can term a “queer diasporic” frame of analysis that pays attention
to the intimate connections between disparate diasporic and national locations
and their convergence around heteronormative gender and sexual ideologies. This
is a particularly urgent and necessary project in the context of South Asia,
given the centrality of the diaspora to the material and ideological maintenance
of Hindu nationalism in India, and in light of the unholy alliance between the
Hindu Right in India and the current Bush regime in the U.S.
Sharyn Graham, Auckland University of Technology
Bisexual and Transgender Intersections in South Sulawesi, Indonesia
This paper analyses the intersections between bisexuality and transgender in
South Sulawesi, Indonesia. While there are no equivalent indigenous terms, there
are cognate identities and experiences that make such an examination valid and
fruitful. The paper is divided into four main sections. After a brief introduction,
section one sets the scene by introducing readers to South Sulawesi. This section
also examines prevailing ideas of gender and sexuality in the region. I argue
that gender is a salient notion in South Sulawesi and that there are very clear
models of what is expected of girls and boys when they grow up. I also posit
that gender is a holistic concept, constituted by various factors, including
biology, sexuality, roles, and behaviours. In the second section I introduce
two gendered identities which fall outside normative models: calabai‚ (transgendered
males) and calalai‚ (transgendered females). Through the narratives of
key informants, the identity and subjectivity of these individuals is revealed.
In the third section I recount specific examples of bisexuality and transgender
intersections. A critical analysis of these intersections reveals much about
representations and understandings of desire, sexuality, and gender. The theoretical
contributions which arise from this analysis are proposed in the fourth section.
I argue that the conceptual categories imposed by rigid Western terminology are
rendered problematic when considering the intersection between bisexuality and
transgender. As such, in South Sulawesi experiences of bisexuality and transgender
must be explored from a perspective which allows appreciation of their coalescence.
Ed Green, University of New South Wales
Living In Rural Areas of Indonesia—The Experience of Gay Men
In his recent doctoral study of Indonesian gay men, Richard Howard (1996) noted ‘that
young men recognizing a same sex desire have moved from smaller villages to the
city to explore their homosexuality and to avoid the pressure to marry’ (p.354).
Howard also claimed that for the gay men in his study, ‘men may express
both homosexual desire and behaviour’ but unless they married they were
unable to see themselves, or be seen by others, as ‘real men’ (laki
asli) (p. 345). This paper, based on interview data gathered from a small sample
of Indonesian gay men living outside metropolitan areas questioned how they saw
themselves and experienced their lives. How did they express and experience (gay)
desire? Did they interact with, resist, or simply bypass the conformity and parochialism
and the religious orthodoxy of the communities within which they live? The men
in this study did come under pressure to marry or to see themselves as less of
a man. But they did perceive themselves as men and they had no intention of conforming
to the pressure from family and society to marry. Nor did they intend moving
to the city to avoid such pressures. This paper asserts that not all gay men
in Asia live in cities and that many chose not to forsake their non-urban lives
and instead found strategies to live their lives in their own way.
Weiguo Gu, Chi Heng Foundation
PFLAG Organizing in China: Recent Experiences
Concerned about the lack of a support network for the marginalised LGBT people
in China such as the Gay movements in the US, the Chi Heng Foundation has started
to organise a Chinese version of PFLAG.
Currently the work focuses on two projects: The first is the construction of
a PFLAG website in Chinese to be used as a starting point to introduce PFLAG
to the general public and get like-minded activists united to work towards the
elimination of discrimination and prejudice against gays, lesbians and other
sexual minorities. The other is the compilation of a book which consists a of
collection of original articles written by accepting family members and friends
of lesbians and gays recounting how they came to be accepting. It is hoped that
such a book will enlighten the misinformed public and increase their understanding
of LGBT people.
Yaqi Guo, Beijing Gender Health Education Institute
The Rapid Development of the LGBT Communities in China
During the 1980s, homosexuals in China were undercover: only personal relationships
existed. The emergence of AIDS brought the existence of ‘homosexuality’ to
the general public for the first time, but it also misled people to think that
homosexuals are filthy, horrifying and contemptible. Due to the neglect shown
towards homosexuals, some LGBT volunteers started to work on publicity and behavior-intervention
against AIDS in the 1990’s. At the same time, small groups of people providing
help to homosexuals also came forth. These were the initial LGBT communities
in China. Entering the new millennium, groups of volunteers mushroomed in LGBT
communities of many places and organized a variety of activities. In 2003, Beijing
Gender Health Education Institute organized a series of activities among homosexuals
in Kunming, Nanjing and Beijing to share experiences and to build the foundation
for further development of local communities.
Odine de Guzman, University of the Philippines
Between Women: Toward a Political Economy of OFW Sexuality
My research focuses on female ‘overseas Filipino workers’ (OFW) in
selected Asian countries and on how the experience of labor migration in an increasingly
globalized world has impacted on their lives. By way of a textual analysis of
the workers’ cultural productions such as letters and narratives—oral
and written—and case studies, I hope to examine the ways by which migrants
interrogate, and even subvert, the usually stringent employer and sending- and
receiving-states regulations as these impinge on the personal and sexual. Specifically,
this presentation is an exploratory analysis of the relationship between neo-liberalism,
labor migration and sexuality as these are played out in the everyday experiences
of Filipino migrant domestic workers. It examines how this triad bears upon the
political economy of an OFW sexuality in light of the growing number of migrant
domestic workers who enter into same-sex relationships, possibly as counter-recourses
to intimacy and affect given migration regulations such as the mandatory pregnancy
tests, the growing incidence of HIV/AIDs among OFWs, if not apparent articulations
of latent desires subsumed under socio-cultural dictates in the home country.
Judith Halberstam, University of Southern California
"
Comparative Female Masculinities"
Recent anthropological work on "same-sex female desire" has been rightly
hesitant about using the term "lesbian" for variations on same sex
desire found in different parts of the globe. Where anthropologists have used
a Euro-American template to read and study same sex female desires in non-Western
contexts, they have run the risk of obliterating alternative sexual economies
and taxonomies. My paper will look at comparative renderings of "female
masculinity," a non-identitarian model of gender, and will ask whether we
can draw any kind of meaningful parallels between "tombois" in Indonesia,
onabes in Japan, T's in Taiwan, toms in Thailand, marimachas in Mexico and tomboys
in the Philippines, just to give a few examples. My paper is less an account
of these different models of gender variance and more of a search for a methodology
for studying gender variance in a comparative framework.
Makoto Hibino, Kansai Queer Film Festival
What is Necessary For Us, For Our Queer Movement in Japan?
I have some proposals for creating changes both in the communities and in majority
society. 1: Ignoring minorities is not only a problem for heterosexuals. We should
think there are lesbians and gays in every classroom. In this same way, we should
also think that there are bisexuals in every LG community. But unfortunately
the title of the pride in Tokyo is ‘Tokyo Lesbian and Gay Parade’.
The problems exist also inside our communities. 2: Some gay activists think homophobia
is the greatest concern. However struggling against homophobia is not enough.
Homophobia is only part of the binary gender system. Challenging the whole binary
gender system is important. We need to remember that sexual orientation, gender
identity, gender role/expression and sex are one thing, one part or one side
of one thing. 3: The mainstream society, queer communities and ourselves are
under the Japanese emperor system Tennou-sei. People want to/tend to think as
if all have the same thoughts and that there are not different opinions within
the community. People customarily tend to follow the authority, and do not accept
their responsibility, because they think they only follow the authority. In the
past, this kind of the Tennou-sei led to the invasion of Asian countries. Inside
Japan, many queers feel strangled by ‘silk floss’. To say "NO!" clearly
and publicly is very difficult inside both queer communities as well as mainstream.
Struggling against the Tennou-sei is necessary, in order to create a new society
which respects personal rights and supports the diversity of ourselves.
Brian Ho, University of Putra Malaysia
Other People’s Stories
This is a qualitative research project looking at all gay, lesbian, bisexual
and transexual clients attending a private psychiatric and psychotherapeutic
practice in the heart of Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. It looks at the attendees’ demographics,
ethnic origins, reasons for seeking professional help, diagnosis and outcome.
Similarities and differences in this population compared to the heterosexual
counterparts are discussed.
Josephine Ho, National Central University Taiwan
Gender Embodiment: Transgender Body/Subject Formations in Taiwan
‘
A soul trapped in the wrong body’ is a common description employed by trans
subjects to explain their unusual condition. This self-characterization includes
two important premises: that the body and the soul (or identity, self-image,
etc.) are two separate and independent entities whose correct alignment makes
up the effect of gender; and that the soul occupies a higher position than the
body, to the extent that any mismatch between the two is to be resolved by modifying
the body (through cross-dressing, hormonal therapy, SRS, or other procedures)
to match the soul. The body-soul imagery may help illuminate the awkward situation
of trans subjects by graphically presenting the often contradictory feelings
and images that trans subjects have to negotiate as they move through social
space. Yet the simple graphic of the body-soul imagery also tends to obscure
the manifold differences among trans subjects, differences that may very well
affect the credibility of their claim to ‘a soul trapped in the wrong body.’ More
importantly, the imagery further conceals ‘the daily effort of doing gender
in everyday interactions that all of us engage in.’ The present paper presents
the various ways in which Taiwanese transgender subjects have forged out of limited
social means and support their own constructions of gender and identity. As the
contradictory and disharmonious body/identity of the transgender subjects struggles
to assert itself despite existing gender stereotypes and prejudices, their self-reflexive
project of doing gender are also constantly ‘trans’-gressing/’trans’-forming
existing gender/sexuality categories.
Loretta Ho, University of Western Australia
Engaging the Gaze of the Gay Community in Beijing
My research explores the form of identity being assumed by the emerging same-sex ‘communities’ in
Beijing. The research seeks to evaluate whether self-identification as tongxinglian,
gay or lesbian, implies an allegiance to ‘shared’ values, ‘group’ identity,
and ‘solidarity’. It also examines to what extent Chinese gay/lesbian
networks and social groups have been influenced by hegemonic ‘global gayness’,
or whether they remain localised and unique in response to local conditions.
This paper presents aspects of my post-fieldwork findings of the same-sex community
in Beijing from a female, heterosexual gaze, which is mediated by assumptions,
or possibly misconceptions, about the Other. I will show how this vantage point,
together with the reflected and reflective gaze of the gay community, shapes
the narratives of the gays and lesbians that I have communicated with and interviewed.
I argue that an appreciation of ways of seeing in the field is central to understanding
how epistemology of the same-sex ‘community’ in Beijing is imagined,
represented, and constructed in an atmosphere which marginalises and silences
their experiences.
Peter Trung Thu Ho, Asian Community AIDS Services, MSM Education and Outreach
Program, Toronto, Canada
The Use and Evaluation of irice.org: An Internet HIV Outreach Targeting Asian
MSM
The purpose of this presentation is to introduce audiences with 'how to' develop
and implement a volunteer-based, on-line HIV education and outreach project.
iRice.org, the Internet website was designed to provide information on HIV/AIDS
on the issues of social dynamics and isolations, more recreational/educational
space for Asian MSM on-line; and to increase positive Asian image on-line. The
presenter will also discuss about evaluation and process at the end.
Guo-Juin Hong, Duke University
Theatrics of Cruising: Bath Houses and Movie Houses in Tsai Ming-liang’s
Films
This paper looks at gay cruising in films by Taiwan’s internationally famed
director, Tsai Ming-liang. I focus on three films, namely, The River (1995),
What Time Is It There? (2001), and Goodbye, Dragon Inn, Goodbye (2002), and locate
a few significant cinematic moments, hoping to show a peculiar movement of desire
in Tsai’s film works. I call it a theatrics of cruising because the intricate
stagings of those activities through chance encounters_be it intentional or misunderstood,
comic or horrific, consummated or interrupted_are a hide-and-go-seek game that
flirts with the film viewers and frustrates their visual participation as much
it does the characters in the films. Never in any straightforward manner, this
theatrics of cruising encourages a reconfiguration of cinematic space; a space,
I will attempt to argue, that effects a different visual economy similar to the
Deleuzian notion of deterritorilization and reterritorialization. A re-vision,
then, of the cinematic space and its identificatory processes is made possible
by such a theatrics at work; at play, too, but perhaps more than a tease.
Yuri Horie, Osaka University
Women’s Activism Against Homophobia: Christian Discourse in the Non-Christian
Society of Japan
Japanese society is often described as a ‘tolerant’ society toward
lesbians and gays, due in no small part to Christianity’s marginal status
and limited cultural influence. Yet, Christian churches in Japan continue to
exclude lesbians and gay men, and church members have internalized discriminatory
consciousness based on the heterosexism present in Japanese society at large.
In this paper, I analyse a case involving the United Church of Christ in Japan
(UCCJ/Kyodan), the largest Protestant denomination in Japan. When a seminarian
who had come out as a gay man took the examination for becoming a pastor in 1998,
the backlash led to the spread of homophobic discourse within the Church. Although
in Western churches lesbians and gays working together have constructed resistance
movements in reaction to such problems, in the case of UCCJ/Kyodan, heterosexual
women and lesbians united in response to the situation. These women recognized
the (hetero)sexist roots of this homophobic discourse and, drawing on their history
of activism against sexism, were motivated to form a movement to resist it. Gay
men, on the other hand, remained silent. In its analysis of this case, this paper
will describe (1) the reality of the ‘intolerance’ toward lesbians
and gay men in Japan, elucidating that in the current climate that discrimination
is concealed rather than non-existent; and (2) potential and limits of women’s
activism against homophobia.
Cliff Ip, University College London
How Should Hong Kong Court Rule on the Constitutionality of Gay Sex?
My paper is based on my master dissertation, submitted for MA Human Rights, University
College London. It argues Hong Kong (HK) court should strike down statutory provisions
which criminalize certain gay sexual acts. It first identifies the recognition
of homosexual rights in various supranational and domestic courts, e.g. The European
Court on Human Rights and the Canadian Supreme Court. Their arguments are examined.
HK should follow these courts in scrutinizing and limiting the conventional morality
claim --- the claim that homosexuality is immoral according to conventional or
popular beliefs --- and in not deferring too much to the legislative body. It
then casts doubt on a general cultural relativist argument, as, for example,
advocated by Prof. Joseph Chan. If the last point is wrong, homosexuality may
still be compatible with Confucianism, the influential school of thought in Hong
Kong, because I) the latter can be “re-interpreted” to protect homosexuals‚ interests
and II) other Confucian places take homosexual rights more seriously than HK.
If the author is still wrong and Confucian thoughts do balance against gay rights,
then a compromise solution which proposes that certain provisions be struck down
is also proposed.
Hitoshi Ishida, Meiji Gakuin University
The 3-D Rigid Structure (1990s) and The Flexible Network (1950s): Two Interpretative
Frameworks on Marginal Sexualities in Post War Japan
The purpose of this paper is to consider interpretative frameworks on marginal
sexualities (‘non-normative sexualities’), directory comparing the
Flexible Network Frameworks of the 1950s and the the 3-D Rigid Structure of the
1990s in Japan. During the 1990s, communities of men who love men and feminized
men deployed terms derived from Anglophone gay and transgender activist discourse,
and began to reflectively differentiate themselves as ‘gay’ and ‘MtF’ (male-to-female
transsexuals). One result of the emergence of this new discourse of ‘sexual
minorities’ was that various marginal sexualities became fixed in a rigid
three-dimensional framework dependent on a combination of three axes (biological
sex, gender identity and sexual orientation). Now this framework is hegemonic
on discourse on marginal sexualities in Japan today. Compared with this 1990s
framework, the 1950s framework was very different indeed, as can be found when
analyzing the hentai (perverse) magazines discourses of the time. The hentai
magazines tended to treat men who love men and feminized men interchangeably.
Significantly, these two categories were often regarded as being representatively
related to other perverse sexual desires such as sadism/masochism and pederasty/uranism
in ad hoc rules. Therefore personal narratives of perverse sexual desire in this
framework were characterized as having a process of bricolage within a flexible
network. In this paper I will suggest that these two frameworks of sexuality
in postwar Japan represent a change over a period of about 40 years from a flexible
network to a rigid structure.
Lorna Quejong Israel, Women & Gender Institute, Miriam College, the Philippines
Inserting Lesbians in Non-Lesbian Spaces: Spectacularisation in Media Coverages
of the Pride March
Recently, Filipino lesbians have gained visibility made possible by the LGBTQ
community and curiosity on lesbians. This has opened options and drawbacks, which
need to be critically scrutinized. Current visibility tend to either render lesbians
as spectacles should they assert their self-defined identity as lesbians or to
subsume them under hetero-normative claims. Either way, lesbians would find themselves
between the conveniences afforded by recognition in hetero-normative regime and
the limitations posed by identities. This panel seeks to present the everyday
claims or denials that lesbians have to make both from the hetero-normative public & within
themselves in order to generate effective, cost-efficient and fun ways of promoting
lesbian politics without undermining their integrity.
Marou Izumo, Independent Scholar
Notes from Chanbara Queen: a queer critique of 1950-1960 Japanese cinema
In this presentation I present my work Chanbara Queen (Pandora, 2003) which offers
a queer critique of mass produced popular, swashbuckling movies from the Golden
Era of Japanese cinema in the 1950s and 1960s. In particular I will focus on
the portrayal of drag kings/drag queens in imaginary Edo period settings and
gender representations therein. I will also discuss the fanatic consumption of
those films by the Japanese public. Films to be discussed include Hanagasa Wakashu
(The Young Man in the Flowered Hat, 1958) starring Misora Hibari, the greatest
singing star of the post-war period, and Yukinojoo henge (The transformations
of Yukinojoo, 1963) featuring the eternal screen beau, Hasegawa Kazuo.
Luke Jacques, Murdoch University
Queering the Culture: Does Gay Discourse Change if We Take Cross-cultural Communication
Seriously?
Body Theory has been an area of growth, ambivalence and politics in the last
twenty years, yet the graft with ‘Asianness’ remains unstable. Beyond
generalized tropes of Orientalism, close textual analysis is required to understand
the sexualized context of the non-Western gay male body. My paper works through
the multiple readings of gay Thai bodies and the opportunity that this study
provides for contemporary Cultural Studies. Through relevant textual analysis,
an examination into cultural meanings, readership practices, and appropriation
by Western media culture probes the relationship between images of gayness‚ and
Thai gay identity. This paper investigates the semiotic construction of queer
discourses in both Thai and Western popular images for both the Thai and western
reader. Within Thai popular culture the Thai gay body is read differently from
a Thai national or Western expatriate perspective. This particular analysis exposes
remnants of Western Orientalist discourses that construct the Thai gay‚ male
body as a highly sexualised, commodified and exoticised site for Western surveillance
and consumption. A critique of how gay is translated, embodied and defined within
representations and images in Thai popular culture demonstrates that Thai queer
communities resist neo-colonialist discourses by selectively appropriating particular
Western gay terminology and identities in order to create distinctly Thai discourses
of gayness
Sachin Jain, Mumbai University
“
Anti-sodomy Laws in India: Harassment & Socio-Cultural
Aspects”
This paper delves into the roots of India's anti-sodomy laws full of vague and
archaic terminologies. I have discussed social factors like patriarchy, the ebb
of socialism and embrace of capitalist ways, satellite television, the internet,
a booming economy, over a billion people, a breakdown of the joint family system,
urban migration, Bollywood cinema the omnipresence of alternate gender identities
like Hijras, Kotis etc. and the tenuous relationship they share with the modern
gay movement. The paper enumerates the effects of anti-sodomy laws in India:
exploitation, extortion, verbal harassment, the perception of gayism as a fancy
western decadence, Recent issues like the peddling of pornography, MMS technologies
in mobile phones, the cheap availability of spycams, the advent of adult television
in India are discussed. Effects of criminalisation: invisiblisation, misinformation,
condoning of and apathy to violence against que
|